Friday, October 30, 2009

Group Objectives

Historical Overview- Angelina
Angelina will be tackling this topic and presenting information along this time line to discuss thoughts and views upon body and gender differences and how they compare to today's ideas about body size and image. Angelina's research will come from scientific journals which show past research on body image and health in relation to historical views. She will also be including a survey, using images of how bodies were depicted in the past, to illustrate any changes that might be present in current opinions.
View Blog Here: http://historical1.blogspot.com/

Literature Review- Angelina/Chelsea/Collin
Angelina/Chelsea/Collin will each articles, two of them which are anthropology related and find information on body image. They will also be discussing the possible causes and onsets of eating disorders including ideas pertaining to the origin of present societal norms in relation to body size and shape.
View Blog Here: http://empiricalresearch0.blogspot.com/

Media/Popular Culture Analysis- Chelsea/Collin
Collin Chiu will be discussing how the media depicts and manipulates the body image of men and its effects. Specifically, he will be looking into magazines that are designed for men, such as Men's Fitness and GQ, and analyzing the articles and advertisements targeted at men's body image.
Chelsea Vosough will investigate what impact the amount and types of advertisements an adolescent in relation to how he/she views themselves, and thus affect the important task of identity formation. She will be doing this by examining several magazine articles, from a variety of magazines. For example, she will be looking at Shape and Cosmopolitan. Furthermore, Chelsea will be analyzing past research and drawing conclusions on whether a relationship is shown between media exposure and its representation of the thin body-image as an ideal of women in relation to a negative effect on the person's self-image that lead to body dissatisfaction.
View Blog Here: http://mediapopculture0.blogspot.com/

Empirical Research- Chelsea/Collin
Collin will conduct a survey based on the thoughts of male students on campus about a specific article on men's body image and how it affects them in a few sentences. Taking the information from the survey and applying it to his analysis of the magazines, he will write a cohesive paper with his thoughts on the current and long-term effects of these magazines. Chelsea will also be doing a survey to examine if media affects body image
View Blog Here: http://empiricalresearch1.blogspot.com/


GRADE SCALE- 10 %

Participation 0-5
*How much time and effort each group member contributed to the weblog.
*How each member communicated throughout the project.
*How much work each member put into their topics.

Performance 5-10
*Each member completed their assignment on time.
* Each member covered their specific topics.
* Each member put quality effort into the assignment and conducted their research properly


Group Discussion

Describe: For women, to be considered attractive they must meet a certain criteria that is heavily influenced by the media and is unrepresentative of the general population. Requirements include but are not limited to a stick thin figure with large breasts. For men, there are similar requirements which include large muscles, and they are expected to be in tip top physical condition. In comparison, a healthy body varies depending on the person.

Discussions: While the media may mediate what is acceptable for body types, it negatively affects the public. In encourages people to pursue bodies that may not be healthy for their lifestyle. Achieving the "Perfect" body is not always possible without starvation, surgery, and/or excessive workout habits. Trying to achieve the perfect body, is mentally and physically straining on a person and can cause serious health issues. The media contributes to the desire for the perfect body by using images that are heavily photo shopped and by refusing to use images on an average body type. However, the media does this especially for magazine sales, based on demand. In general, people want to view someone who is considered attractive based on the media's standards. There isn't demand for "Average" looking people. Unfortunately, because average looking aren't present in television shows, movies and magazines, it can also lead to the unhealthy pursuit for the perfect body, which can lead to eating disorders and body dysmorphia. The concerns over achieving what people believe are the perfect weight and size relation to the media are blind to the healthier and more realistic goals using tools such as Body Mass Index (BMI) calculators. Using the BMI is a more reliable way to find out what a healthy size and weight is for your height an age. People comparing themselves to images of people that look "perfect" in the media may drive them to the end trying to attain the exact image if not beyond.

7 comments:

  1. I participated in a study at Cal State San Marcos where they found that flipping through a magazine (not scholarly...more like Cosmopolitan or something) for 5 minutes would lower self-esteem. This is defintely true and we need to shed light on this subject so that a healthy body can be the ideal rather than having to go through drastic dangerous measures to feel as pretty as the models we see in the media everyday.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I personally dont agree with what you are saying about the media causing strain on a person because they think they have to look a certain way and what not. I do agree that the media influences one to want to look a certain way but doesnt necessarily have an effect on how we think of ourselves. In class the other day I overheard a girl say that the media makes her feel fat and ugly so I looked at her and ummm SHE'S SO SKINNY! it was insane for a person to be sooooooo influenced by the media that they would call themselves fat when they are rocking a size two. Its crazy. I for one and content with my body and dont think the media has much influence over the way I perceive myself. and yes there are some not so perfect people in the media...ANTM for one displays a grip of young women that are not perfect... they are awkward looking but just have the right moves and are photogenic...they are not perfect...just be content with yourself, exercise and stop caring about the media so much...relax!
    [Christina Lopez]

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that the media does display many models that have perfect bodies. However, that doesn't necessarily make everyone’s self-esteem decrease drastically. I actually am motivated to become healthier and to more active in my life because of the “perfect” bodies that are shown on television or magazines. Looking at images of people with perfect bodies makes me want to workout harder in the gym, and be in the best physical shape possible in a healthy manner. I believe that people who gain low-self esteem by looking at these perfected images need to psychologically accept themselves for who they are, and if they aren’t happy with what they look like then they should do something to fix their image in a healthy way. [Vanessa Lopez]

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that images in magazines influence people however I also agree with the other comment that people need tone happy with themselves. I can't believe the media make skeletons seem normal and who we should strive to look like. I heard on the radio a few weeks ago that celvin Klein fired their model of 8 years because she couldn't fit in the clothes anymore. She is 5'10 and 120 pounds. This is crazy! Fashion should model their cloths on the size of the person who is buying them. -marie group1

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also agree that media has some influence on people over their bodies. medias idea of a "perfect" body is disturbing. I do not see how a skeleton looking girl is hot. The model mentioned is fillipa hamilton and she worked for ralph lauren and they believe she was fired for being "to large". they also digitally altered her in an advertisement so that she could look really skinny to me she looks scary!
    - jessica group 8

    ReplyDelete
  6. Advertisers often emphasize sexuality and the importance of physical attractiveness in an attempt to sell products, but researchers are concerned that this places undue pressure on women and men to focus on their appearance.

    Media is not always a bad thing. I have known some people that are overweight and want to be like a certain person from ads or tv show. It rarely happens i know, but they did end up losing their weight and working out to have a better healthier lifestyle.[David]

    ReplyDelete